They Read Hundreds of Books a Year. How Do They Pick the Top 10?
The New York Times • 12/14/2025 • Last cited 12/14/2025
Summary
The New York Times Book Review's process for selecting its annual top 10 books involves extensive discussions and disagreements among its team, with occasional moments of consensus. The article highlights the complexities and dynamics of this decision-making process.
Lindy Score Breakdown
35
Age (0-35)
32 days
40
Velocity (0-40)
1 source (low traction)
8
Tier (0-10)
The New York Times
0
Breadth (0-15)
1 unique
Total Score83/100
Score BreakdownRisk 35
Source Reputation: Moderate trust (8/20 pts)
Consensus: Single source - no independent confirmation yet
Age: 32 days - proven survivor
Stories gain Lindy status through source reputation, network consensus, and time survival.
Breaking Similar stories
We’re Empty Nesters Now. What Do We Do?
The New York Times • Today
How Can I Support a Depressed Friend?
The New York Times • Today
Men’s Coats That Make a Strong Impression
The New York Times • Today
Book Review: ‘Fly, Wild Swans,’ by Jung Chang
The New York Times • Today
As Megadeth Counts Down to Extinction, Dave Mustaine Opens Up
The New York Times • Today
White Lies, Inner Truth: The Contradictions of Henri Rousseau
The New York Times • Today
‘A Private Life’ Review: Jodie Foster Uncovers a Twisty Plot in Paris
The New York Times • Today
‘A Useful Ghost’ Review: Machine Yearning
The New York Times • Today
‘Deepfaking Sam Altman’ Review: Altmanesque
The New York Times • Today
Amol Rajan to leave Radio 4's Today programme
BBC • Today
Anti-Lindy Similar stories
The Art of a Good Awards-Show Speech
The New York Times • 1 day ago
Cross-Country Skiing in Jackson Hole, Wyoming
The New York Times • 1 day ago
Saks Files for Bankruptcy as Department Stores Fight for Survival
The New York Times • 2 days ago
Leonardo DiCaprio Is Honored at Annual National Board of Review Gala
The New York Times • 1 day ago
Applying Richard Foreman’s Off-Kilter Aesthetic (and Ducks) to Opera
The New York Times • 1 day ago
What the Bankruptcy of Saks Means for You
The New York Times • 2 days ago
Book Review: ‘The Summer My Mother Had Green Eyes,’ by Tatiana Tibuleac
The New York Times • 1 day ago
Harper Lee Expanded on Her View of the South in Letters to a Friend
The New York Times • 1 day ago
You Don’t Need a Trip to Florida, You Just Need a Cozy Restaurant
The New York Times • 2 days ago
Jim McBride Dies at 78; Brought Honky-Tonk Back to Country Music
The New York Times • 1 day ago