Our Favorite Hidden Gem Books of 2025

The New York Times • 12/11/2025 • Last cited 12/14/2025

Summary

The New York Times' Book Review staff has compiled a list of their favorite hidden gem books for 2025, highlighting titles that made their personal best-of-the-year selections. The recommendations aim to showcase unforgettable reads that may not have received widespread attention.

Share:XRedditLinkedIn

Lindy Score Breakdown

35
Age (0-35)
34 days
4
Velocity (0-40)
1 source (low traction)
8
Tier (0-10)
The New York Times
0
Breadth (0-15)
1 unique
Total Score47/100

Related Story Timeline

  1. 2025-10-23
    Horror Movie Producer Jason Blum on His Favorite Books (The New York Times)
  2. 2025-11-02
    Big Stars at LACMA’s Big Night (The New York Times)
  3. 2025-12-01
    The Most Interesting Wine Books of 2025 (The New York Times)
  4. 2025-12-02
    Jafar Panahi, Who Filmed in Secret in Iran, Wins Big at Gotham Awards (The New York Times)
  5. 2025-12-11
    Our Favorite Hidden Gem Books of 2025 (current)

Score BreakdownRisk 35

Source Reputation: Moderate trust (8/20 pts)
Consensus: Single source - no independent confirmation yet
Age: 34 days - proven survivor

Stories gain Lindy status through source reputation, network consensus, and time survival.

Breaking Similar stories

Julian Barnes on his last novel: 'I hope it's a good one to go out on'
BBC • Today
Can the American Oboe Sing Again?
The New York Times • Today
Dramas Keep Showing Us Hapless Men — and Hypercompetent Women
The New York Times • Today
Harper Lee Expanded on Her View of the South in Letters to a Friend
The New York Times • Today
Book Review: ‘The Summer My Mother Had Green Eyes,’ by Tatiana Tibuleac
The New York Times • Today
Wicked's Ariana Grande and Jonathan Bailey set for theatre reunion
BBC • Today
Jim McBride Dies at 78; Brought Honky-Tonk Back to Country Music
The New York Times • Today
Tony Dokoupil’s Road Trip on CBS News Hits a Rough Patch
The New York Times • Today
Want Your MTV? A Rogue Site Is Bringing Back the Videos.
The New York Times • Today
The Art of a Good Awards-Show Speech
The New York Times • Today

Anti-Lindy Similar stories

What the Bankruptcy of Saks Means for You
The New York Times • 1 day ago
You Don’t Need a Trip to Florida, You Just Need a Cozy Restaurant
The New York Times • 1 day ago
Saks Files for Bankruptcy as Department Stores Fight for Survival
The New York Times • 1 day ago
Read the full story on The New York Times ↗