‘We Were Liars’ Season 2 Casts Young Versions of the Sinclairs as Show Travels Back to Summer of 1999

Variety5/7/2026

Summary

“We Were Liars” Season 2 has announced the casting of six new members as the series prepares to explore the summer of 1999 at Beechwood Island. This season will feature younger versions of the Sinclair family, providing a backstory that takes place two and a half decades before the events of the first season. Among the new cast members, Josh Dallas, known for his roles in “Manifest” and “Once Upon a Time,” will portray young Harris Sinclair. In addition to Dallas, the cast includes Costa D’Angelo, recognized for his work in “Tell Me Lies” and the upcoming “East of Eden,” who will play a new character named Pfeff. Other notable cast members include Peyton List from “The Rookie,” Madison Wolfe from “True Detective,” and Parker Lapaine from “House of the Dragon.” The addition of these actors aims to enrich the narrative by delving into the characters' pasts and their experiences during that pivotal summer. The decision to cast younger versions of the Sinclairs indicates a significant shift in storytelling for the series, allowing viewers to gain insight into the characters' formative years. This approach is expected to deepen the audience's understanding of the dynamics within the Sinclair family and the events that shaped their lives. The anticipation for Season 2 is building as fans look forward to this exploration of the characters' history.

Share:XRedditLinkedIn

Advertisement

Lindy Score Breakdown (V4.2)

6d
Age
2
Sources
from cluster
152
Hours Since Seen
Final Score3/100
CategoryAntiLindy
StatusActive
Recency Multiplier11% (0.5^152/48)
Hero EligibleYes

Story Timeline

  1. 2026-05-07
    ‘We Were Liars’ Season 2 Casts Young Versions of the Sinclairs as Show Travels Back to Summer of 1999 (current)

Score BreakdownRisk 35

Source Reputation: Low-trust source (6/20 pts)
Consensus: Emerging consensus: 2 sources
Age: 6 days - proven survivor

Stories gain Lindy status through source reputation, network consensus, and time survival.

Same Story from 2 sources

Breaking Similar stories

Anti-Lindy Similar stories