Mikayla Matthews Says That “The Only Reason” She’s Leaving Hulu’s ‘Mormon Wives’ Is “Because I Was Told A Certain Person Was Coming Back”

Mikayla Matthews has announced her departure from the reality series "The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives." In an Instagram post, she stated, "I made my decision over a week ago, after hearing some news, that I will not be continuing the show at this moment." Matthews confirmed that her exit was influenced by the return of fellow cast member Taylor Frankie Paul, saying, “The only reason I’m leaving is because I was told a certain person was coming back” (Deadline). She emphasized that there is "no amount of money worth going against my morals," indicating her decision was rooted in personal ethics (Deadline). The series is currently filming its sixth season in Italy, following a tumultuous fifth season that was affected by legal issues surrounding Paul, including domestic violence claims from her ex-partner Dakota Mortensen (Variety). Despite these controversies, Taylor Frankie Paul is confirmed to be returning to production for the new season, although Hulu has not commented on her involvement (Variety). Matthews' exit comes amid ongoing tension within the cast and the broader MomTok community, which has been exacerbated by the controversies surrounding Paul. Matthews described her feelings about the situation as "wrong and unethical," highlighting the impact of personal morals on reality television (Variety). Her departure marks a significant shift in the show's lineup as it moves forward with filming. The dynamics within the cast have been strained, and her exit underscores the challenges faced by reality television stars when navigating personal ethics and professional commitments. The ongoing tensions within the cast and the MomTok community continue to shape the narrative surrounding "The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives" as it progresses into its sixth season (Hollywood Reporter).